BMJ Open (Jun 2025)

What is the Zanzibari craftswomen’s experience on eyeglass use, business challenges and solutions? Participatory action research using solicited diaries and listening workshop narratives

  • Ving Fai Chan,
  • Fatma Omar,
  • Eden Mashayo,
  • Christine Graham,
  • Ronnie Graham,
  • Omar Juma Othman,
  • Kajal Shah,
  • Bhagyalaxmi Shivalingam Pillai,
  • Eleanor Holland

DOI
https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2024-090883
Journal volume & issue
Vol. 15, no. 6

Abstract

Read online

Objective To present older presbyopic Zanzibari craftswomen’s firsthand experiences with the eyeglasses, the challenges they face in advancing their businesses and proposed solutions to these challenges.Design This participatory action research used solicited diaries, where 10 craftswomen documented their experiences with presbyopia correction for 6 months. The diaries were translated into English for qualitative content analysis. Researchers then held a 2-day listening workshop with 20 craftswomen to discuss the diary findings and gather their perspectives on challenges and solutions. These workshops included group discussions and debates to encourage open communication. Narrative analysis was conducted to identify the key narratives.Setting Zanzibar, Unguja and Pemba Islands.Participants Zanzibari craftswomen entrepreneurs with corrected presbyopia, 40 years and older.Intervention Presbyopia near vision eyeglasses for 6 months.Results The study found that improved vision with eyeglasses significantly benefits craftswomen in Zanzibar. They experience increased work efficiency, quality and income. Craftswomen also reported greater independence, confidence and participation in daily activities. However, limited market access and competition restrict their income growth. Business skills training in areas like marketing and finance is seen as a solution for sustainable success.Conclusions Improved near vision was associated with enhanced productivity, financial confidence and well-being among craftswomen. However, persistent barriers—including limited market access, competition and lack of business skills—highlight that a vision-only approach may not address the intersectional challenges faced by older women entrepreneurs in Zanzibar. These findings suggest that integrated strategies combining vision care with business mentoring may offer more sustainable support.