False-Positive Diagnosis of Congenital Heart Defects at First-Trimester Ultrasound: An Italian Multicentric Study

Abstract

Objective. Our objective was to assess the proportion of false-positive CHD cases at the first-trimester evaluation of the fetal heart, performed by experienced operators. Methods. This multicenter retrospective study included of pregnant women with suspicion of CHDs during first-trimester screening for aneuploidies. In all cases, the fetal heart assessments were performed by obstetricians with extensive experience in first-trimester scanning, following an extended protocol proposed by SIEOG national guidelines, which included an axial view of the fetal abdomen and chest to assess visceral situs and evaluation of the four-chamber view (4CV) and three-vessel trachea view (3VTV) with color Doppler. In all suspected cases, fetal echocardiography was offered within 16 and/or at 19–22 weeks’ gestation. Results. From a population of 4300 fetuses, 46 CHDs were suspected. Twenty-four cases were excluded from this analysis because the parents opted for early termination of the pregnancies due to associated structural and/or genetic anomalies. For the remaining 22, echocardiography was performed by 16 weeks in 14 cases (64%) and after 16 weeks in 8 cases. In 19 cases (86.4%), a fetal cardiologist confirmed the presence of a CHD. In three cases (13%), the cardiac anatomy was found to be normal at the fetal echocardiography and postnatally. Conclusions. This study shows that the proportion of false-positive cases at the first-trimester ultrasound examination of the fetal heart, performed by experienced operators, may carry a higher risk of false-positive diagnosis than expected. Therefore, this issue must be discussed in instances where a CHD is suspected at the first-trimester screening.

Keywords

• congenital heart defects
• first-trimester ultrasound
• nuchal translucency
• fetal echocardiography
• ultrasound screening