Inferring Population HIV Viral Load From a Single HIV Clinic’s Electronic Health Record: Simulation Study With a Real-World Example

Abstract

BackgroundPopulation viral load (VL), the most comprehensive measure of the HIV transmission potential, cannot be directly measured due to lack of complete sampling of all people with HIV. ObjectiveA given HIV clinic’s electronic health record (EHR), a biased sample of this population, may be used to attempt to impute this measure. MethodsWe simulated a population of 10,000 individuals with VL calibrated to surveillance data with a geometric mean of 4449 copies/mL. We sampled 3 hypothetical EHRs from (A) the source population, (B) those diagnosed, and (C) those retained in care. Our analysis imputed population VL from each EHR using sampling weights followed by Bayesian adjustment. These methods were then tested using EHR data from an HIV clinic in Delaware. ResultsFollowing weighting, the estimates moved in the direction of the population value with correspondingly wider 95% intervals as follows: clinic A: 4364 (95% interval 1963-11,132) copies/mL; clinic B: 4420 (95% interval 1913-10,199) copies/mL; and clinic C: 242 (95% interval 113-563) copies/mL. Bayesian-adjusted weighting further improved the estimate. ConclusionsThese findings suggest that methodological adjustments are ineffective for estimating population VL from a single clinic’s EHR without the resource-intensive elucidation of an informative prior.