Tailored opening questions to the context of using medical questionnaires: Qualitative analysis in first‐visit consultations

Abstract

Abstract Background Communication skills required for doctors do not consist of simple uses of particular linguistic forms but include uses that are sensitive to the interactional context. In consultations where the doctors have pre‐existing information about their patients, this can complicate the context of problem solicitation. We investigated how doctors tailor opening questions to a context in which they get pre‐existing information from a medical questionnaire (MQ) filled out by the patients. Methods The data for this study were 87 video recordings of first visits to the department of general medicine at a university hospital in Japan. We qualitatively analyzed doctors' practices in problem solicitation in an opening phase using conversation analysis and triangulated it with quantitative analysis. Results Open‐ended questions accounted for 26.4% of opening questions. Among the closed‐ended questions, 75.0% were confirming questions about symptoms. In cases with open‐ended questions, doctors minimized the relevance of the MQ to problem solicitation by giving license to repeat the description from the MQ. In cases with closed‐ended questions, doctors highlighted the relevance of the MQ by sharing the MQ. Through these practices, they avoided patients' possible confusion about problem presentation while simultaneously maximizing the possibility of soliciting the patients' narratives. Conclusions Doctors adjusted the level of relevance of pre‐existing information to problem solicitation through both verbal and nonverbal management of the MQ. It will be useful to instruct such context‐dependent practices to improve communication skills in medical school curriculum.

Keywords

• conversation analysis
• general medicine
• medical questionnaire
• opening question
• pre‐existing information
• problem presentation