Revista de Nefrología, Diálisis y Trasplante (Jan 2014)

Parathyroidectomy in chronic kidney disease patients in Argentina: pre surgical studies, types of surgery, recurrence and persistence

  • Adriana Peñalba,
  • Elisa Del Valle,
  • Armando Luis Negri,
  • Alberto Alles,
  • Walter Douthat,
  • E. Dhole,
  • María Teresa Ferrero,
  • Ramón Giachi,
  • G. Gómez,
  • Antonio Grbavac Drago,
  • A. Hansen,
  • E. Hernández,
  • G. Ibañez,
  • Aldo Lafalla,
  • A. Lara,
  • L. León,
  • Guillermo Rosa Diez,
  • Cecilia Mengarelli,
  • Vicente Altobelli,
  • Luis Rolando Urtiaga,
  • Adriana Aralde,
  • Gustavo Aguirre,
  • F. Chávez,
  • Alicia Citarelli,
  • Ricardo Cutrona,
  • Fernando De Rosa,
  • H. López,
  • M. Lludgard,
  • Yanina Maccio,
  • Amalia Teresa Marcozzi,
  • Claudio Mascheroni,
  • Héctor Moretto,
  • Matías Najún,
  • M Norri,
  • Fernando J. Perretta,
  • Marcelo Puddu,
  • C. Scifo,
  • Silvia Setti,
  • Rodolfo Wilberg,
  • L. Zárate,
  • Juan Carlos Ziella

Journal volume & issue
Vol. 34, no. 1
pp. 13 – 20

Abstract

Read online

Introduction: Parathyroidectomy (PTx) is the selecte treatment for patients with severe secondary hyperparathyroidism, refractory to medical treatment. There is not enough information about this procedure in Argentina, that is the reason why we performed this study. Methods: 255 patients with PTx were included from the year 2003 to 2007 on a voluntary register. Studies of pre-surgical localization, phosphocalcic metabolism laboratories before and after surgery were evaluated, and the type of surgical technique used. The persistence and recurrence of post-surgical hyperparathyroidism was analyzed. Results: The PTx rate was 2,7/1000 patients year. 83% of the patients had neck echography and 59% Sestamibi scans with Tc 99. There was a positive correlation (p<0,001) between the number of detected glands by echography and Sestamibi. The parathyroidectomy performed was: subtotal in 77%, total with self-implant in 14% and total without self-implant in 9%. There were significant falls of Ca and P, Alkaline Phosphatase and PTH (1744±788 pg/ml to 247±450 pg/ml; p<0.0001) post-surgical. 2.4 ±2,5 months after the PTx, 72% of patients had PTH <2 50 pg/ml, 19,8% had persistence and 8,3% had recurrence. According to the type of surgery, the persistence and recurrence were for subtotal PTx 22% and 8,3%, total PTx with implant 11% and 11%, and total PTx without selfimplant 13% and 4% respectively. The performance of the Sestamibi scan did not affect the PTx results. No noticeable differences were observed among the centers for persistence and recurrence. Conclusions: The PTx rate was very low, echography was the preferred method of pre-surgical localization, and subtotal PTx was the most used surgical technique. PTx was successful in most of the patients, and persistence and recurrence were not related to the technique.

Keywords