Calibration for Improving the Medium-Range Soil Temperature Forecast of a Semiarid Region over Tibet: A Case Study

Abstract

The high complexity of the parameter–simulation problem in land surface models over semiarid areas makes it difficult to reasonably estimate the surface simulation conditions that are important for both weather and climate in different regions. In this study, using the dense site datasets of a typical semiarid region over Tibet and the Noah land surface model with the constrained land parameters of multiple sites, an enhanced Kling–Gupta efficiency criterion comprising multiple objectives, including variable and layer dimensions, was obtained, which was then applied to calibration schemes based on two global search algorithms (particle swarm optimization and shuffled complex evaluation) to investigate the site-scale spatial complexities in soil temperature simulations. The calibrations were then compared and further validated. The results show that the Noah land surface model obtained reasonable simulations of soil moisture against the observations with fine consistency, but the negative fit and huge spatial errors compared with the observations indicated its weak ability to simulate the soil temperature over regional semiarid land. Both calibration schemes significantly improved the soil moisture and temperature simulations, but particle swarm optimization generally converged to a better objective than shuffled complex evaluation, although with more parameter uncertainties and less heterogeneity. Moreover, simulations initialized with the optimal parameter tables for the calibrations obtained similarly sustainable improvements for soil moisture and temperature, as well as good consistency with the existing soil reanalysis. In particular, the soil temperature simulation errors for particle swarm optimization were unbiased, while those for the other method were found to be biased around −3 K. Overall, particle swarm optimization was preferable when conducting soil temperature simulations, and it may help mitigate the efforts in surface forecast improvement over semiarid regions.

Keywords

• multi-objective calibration
• Kling–Gupta efficiency
• soil temperature
• land surface parameters
• soil moisture