Culturally-aligned clinical leadership competencies for effective teamwork in Japanese healthcare

Abstract

Abstract Background Clinical leadership competencies for effective teamwork differ between Western cultures, where an independent self-construal prevails, and Japanese society, where the self-construal is rooted in interdependence. Although 27 out of 82 Japanese medical schools have ‘leadership’ as an educational outcome, specific competencies are poorly described, hindering the development of contextually-relevant leadership education. This study aimed to identify clinical leadership competencies and articulate the attributes and skills fundamental to leadership as perceived by Japanese physicians. Methods The 80 items of the UK clinical leadership competency framework (CLCF) formed the stimulus in a modified Delphi. Participants, comprising 26 Japanese physicians, rated the importance of each item using a 5-point Likert scale with free-text comments regarding the modification of competencies and suggestions for new items. Items were eliminated if the Likert mean was less than 4.0 and if fewer than 70% of participants considered them to be important. Newly described or modified items derived from free-text comments were rated for importance in a second round with reflective thematic analysis of the free-text descriptions. Results A CLCF of 84 items, reflective of Japanese clinical leadership, was created by eliminating three items describing tasks rarely involving Japanese physician leaders, revising seven items to emphasize understanding of members, and adding seven items to maximize feelings of team comfort. Seven skills and attributes emerged to construct Japanese clinical leadership from thematic analysis. “Humility” was viewed as a fundamental to leadership. Humility-driven “self-discipline” and “attentive listening”, “supporting members” and “guiding members” with humility-based compassion, were essential elements to create “psychological safety” for freedom of expression. Achieving “unity” through emotional integration was identified as the overall goal of leadership. Conclusions The reorganized CLCF has embedded more member-centered behaviors that build rapport and comfort for the members than the original CLCF. Modeling the Confucian virtue of humility and building unity by acting with compassion toward members are characteristics of Japanese clinical leadership that reflect an interdependent social context. These findings are a step toward the development of leadership education aligned with a Japanese context.

Keywords

• Clinical leadership
• Teamwork
• Competency framework
• Sociocultural context
• Modified Delphi