Frontiers in Earth Science (Sep 2021)

An Assessment of Recently Released High-Degree Global Geopotential Models Based on Heterogeneous Geodetic and Ocean Data

  • Yihao Wu,
  • Xiufeng He,
  • Zhicai Luo,
  • Hongkai Shi

DOI
https://doi.org/10.3389/feart.2021.749611
Journal volume & issue
Vol. 9

Abstract

Read online

The development of the global geopotential model (GGM) broadens its applications in ocean science, which emphasizes the importance for model assessment. We assess the recently released high-degree GGMs over the South China Sea through heterogeneous geodetic observations and synthetic/ocean reanalysis data. The comparisons with a high resolution (∼3 km) airborne gravimetric survey over the Paracel Islands show that XGM2019e_2159 has relatively high quality, where the standard deviation (SD) of the misfits against the airborne gravity data is ∼3.1 mGal. However, the comparisons with local airborne/shipborne gravity data hardly discriminate the qualities of other GGMs that have or truncated to the same expansion degree. Whereas, the comparisons with the synthetic/ocean reanalysis data demonstrate that the qualities of the values derived from different GGMs are not identical, and the ones derived from XGM2019e_2159 have better performances. The SD of the misfits between the mean dynamic topography (MDT) derived from XGM2019e_2159 and the ocean data is 2.5 cm; and this value changes to 7.1 cm/s (6.8 cm/s) when the associated zonal (meridian) geostrophic velocities are assessed. In contrast, the values derived from the other GGMs show deteriorated qualities compared to those derived from XGM2019e_2159. In particular, the contents computed from the widely used EGM2008 have relatively poor qualities, which is reduced by 3.9 cm when the MDT is assessed, and by 4.0 cm/s (5.5 cm/s) when the zonal (meridian) velocities are assessed, compared to the results derived from XGM2019e_2159. The results suggest that the choice of a GGM in oceanographic study is crucial, especially over coastal zones. Moreover, the synthetic/ocean data sets may be served as additional data sources for global/regional gravity field assessment, which are useful in regions that lack of high-quality geodetic data.

Keywords