EClinicalMedicine (Aug 2023)

Safety and immunogenicity of a variant-adapted SARS-CoV-2 recombinant protein vaccine with AS03 adjuvant as a booster in adults primed with authorized vaccines: a phase 3, parallel-group studyResearch in context

  • Guy de Bruyn,
  • Joyce Wang,
  • Annie Purvis,
  • Martin Sanchez Ruiz,
  • Haritha Adhikarla,
  • Saad Alvi,
  • Matthew I. Bonaparte,
  • Daniel Brune,
  • Agustin Bueso,
  • Richard M. Canter,
  • Maria Angeles Ceregido,
  • Sachin Deshmukh,
  • David Diemert,
  • Adam Finn,
  • Remi Forrat,
  • Bo Fu,
  • Julie Gallais,
  • Paul Griffin,
  • Marie-Helene Grillet,
  • Owen Haney,
  • Jeffrey A. Henderson,
  • Marguerite Koutsoukos,
  • Odile Launay,
  • Federico Martinon Torres,
  • Roger Masotti,
  • Nelson L. Michael,
  • Juliana Park,
  • Doris Maribel Rivera-Medina,
  • Natalya Romanyak,
  • Chris Rook,
  • Lode Schuerman,
  • Lawrence D. Sher,
  • Fernanda Tavares-Da-Silva,
  • Ashley Whittington,
  • Roman M. Chicz,
  • Sanjay Gurunathan,
  • Stephen Savarino,
  • Saranya Sridhar,
  • Guy de Bruyn,
  • Joyce Wang,
  • Annie Purvis,
  • Martin Sanchez Ruiz,
  • Haritha Adhikarla,
  • Saad Alvi,
  • Matthew I. Bonaparte,
  • Daniel Brune,
  • Agustin Bueso,
  • Richard M. Canter,
  • Maria Angeles Ceregido,
  • Sachin Deshmukh,
  • David Diemert,
  • Adam Finn,
  • Remi Forrat,
  • Bo Fu,
  • Julie Gallais,
  • Paul Griffin,
  • Marie-Helene Grillet,
  • Owen Haney,
  • Jeffrey A. Henderson,
  • Marguerite Koutsoukos,
  • Odile Launay,
  • Federico Martinon Torres,
  • Roger Masotti,
  • Nelson L. Michael,
  • Juliana Park,
  • Doris Maribel Rivera-Medina,
  • Natalya Romanyak,
  • Chris Rook,
  • Lode Schuerman,
  • Lawrence D. Sher,
  • Fernanda Tavares-Da-Silva,
  • Ashley Whittington,
  • Roman M. Chicz,
  • Sanjay Gurunathan,
  • Stephen Savarino,
  • Saranya Sridhar,
  • Allaw Mohammed,
  • Babin Valérie,
  • Babyak Jennifer,
  • Ines Ben-Ghezala,
  • Thomas Breuer,
  • Corinne Breymeier,
  • Anne Conrad,
  • Ciarrah Holmqvist,
  • Cristiana Costa-Araujo,
  • Florence Coux,
  • Christine Dellanno,
  • Bertrand Dussol,
  • Brandon Essink,
  • Jesús Garrido,
  • Pierre-Olivier Girodet,
  • Claudia Gonzalez,
  • Marie-Ange Grosbois,
  • Justin Hammond,
  • Chelsea He,
  • Ciarrah Homlqvist,
  • Kathy Hudzina,
  • Mark Hutchens,
  • Peta-Gay Jackson Booth,
  • Arnel Joaquin,
  • Rama Kandasamy,
  • Jennifer Kasztejna,
  • Michael Keefer,
  • Murray Kimmel,
  • Matthew Kresge,
  • Fabrice Laine,
  • Maeva Lefebvre,
  • Denise Lopez,
  • Malaborbor Perpetua Lourdes,
  • Zoha Maakaroun-Vermesse,
  • Caitlin Malishchak,
  • Lisa Menard,
  • Sandra Mendoza,
  • Patrick Moore,
  • Mounika Mulamalla,
  • Patrick Mulholland,
  • Jean-Francois Nicolas,
  • Onyema Ogbuagu,
  • Juan Ortiz,
  • Ana Paula Perroud,
  • Gina Peyton,
  • Ya-Fen Purvis,
  • Vanessa Raabe,
  • Enrique Rivas,
  • Nadine Rouphael,
  • Beatrice Roy,
  • Lola Sagot,
  • Nessryne Sater,
  • Howard Schwartz,
  • Randall Severance,
  • Jiayuan Shi,
  • Magdalena Sobieszczyk,
  • Charlene Stevens,
  • Tran Phuong Thuy,
  • Ramy Toma,
  • Tina Tong,
  • Sophie Tourneux,
  • John Treanor,
  • Núria Turet,
  • Rachel Froget,
  • Stephen Walsh,
  • Judith White,
  • Victor del Campo Perez,
  • Lina Perez Breva,
  • Pablo Rojo Conejo,
  • Maria Belen Ruiz Antoraz,
  • Toong Chin,
  • Charlotte Fribbens,
  • Adrian Phillipson,
  • Rachel Kaminski,
  • Stevan Emmett,
  • Corey Hebert,
  • Thomas Birch,
  • Russell Roberson,
  • Jeffrey Zacher,
  • Sophie Gelu-Maury,
  • Loron Loryne,
  • Yvonne Davis

Journal volume & issue
Vol. 62
p. 102109

Abstract

Read online

Summary: Background: In a parallel-group, international, phase 3 study (ClinicalTrials.gov NCT04762680), we evaluated prototype (D614) and Beta (B.1.351) variant recombinant spike protein booster vaccines with AS03-adjuvant (CoV2 preS dTM-AS03). Methods: Adults, previously primed with mRNA (BNT162b2, mRNA-1273), adenovirus-vectored (Ad26.CoV2.S, ChAdOx1nCoV-19) or protein (CoV2 preS dTM-AS03 [monovalent D614; MV(D614)]) vaccines were enrolled between 29 July 2021 and 22 February 2022. Participants were stratified by age (18–55 and ≥ 56 years) and received one of the following CoV2 preS dTM-AS03 booster formulations: MV(D614) (n = 1285), MV(B.1.351) (n = 707) or bivalent D614 + B.1.351 (BiV; n = 625). Unvaccinated adults who tested negative on a SARS-CoV-2 rapid diagnostic test (control group, n = 479) received two primary doses, 21 days apart, of MV(D614). Anti-D614G and anti-B.1.351 antibodies were evaluated using validated pseudovirus (lentivirus) neutralization (PsVN) assay 14 days post-booster (day [D]15) in 18–55-year-old BNT162b2-primed participants and compared with those pre-booster (D1) and on D36 in 18–55-year-old controls (primary immunogenicity endpoints). PsVN titers to Omicron BA.1, BA.2 and BA.4/5 subvariants were also evaluated. Safety was evaluated over a 12-month follow-up period. Planned interim analyses are presented up to 14 days post-last vaccination for immunogenicity and over a median duration of 5 months for safety. Findings: All three boosters elicited robust anti-D614G or -B.1.351 PsVN responses for mRNA, adenovirus-vectored and protein vaccine-primed groups. Among BNT162b2-primed adults (18–55 years), geometric means of the individual post-booster versus pre-booster titer ratio (95% confidence interval [CI]) were: for MV (D614), 23.37 (18.58–29.38) (anti-D614G); for MV(B.1.351), 35.41 (26.71–46.95) (anti-B.1.351); and for BiV, 14.39 (11.39–18.28) (anti-D614G) and 34.18 (25.84–45.22 (anti-B.1.351). GMT ratios (98.3% CI) versus post-primary vaccination GMTs in controls, were: for MV(D614) booster, 2.16 (1.69; 2.75) [anti-D614G]; for MV(B.1.351), 1.96 (1.54; 2.50) [anti-B.1.351]; and for BiV, 2.34 (1.84; 2.96) [anti-D614G] and 1.39 (1.09; 1.77) [anti-B.1.351]. All booster formulations elicited cross-neutralizing antibodies against Omicron BA.2 (across priming vaccine subgroups), Omicron BA.1 (BNT162b2-primed participants) and Omicron BA.4/5 (BNT162b2-primed participants and MV D614-primed participants). Similar patterns in antibody responses were observed for participants aged ≥56 years. Reactogenicity tended to be transient and mild-to-moderate severity in all booster groups. No safety concerns were identified. Interpretation: CoV2 preS dTM-AS03 boosters demonstrated acceptable safety and elicited robust neutralizing antibodies against multiple variants, regardless of priming vaccine. Funding: Sanofi and Biomedical Advanced Research and Development Authority (BARDA).

Keywords