Analytical Approaches to World Music (Aug 2020)

Response to “Global Notation as a Tool for Cross-Cultural and Comparative Music Analysis”

  • Bauer, Amy

Journal volume & issue
Vol. 8, no. 2
pp. 280 – 286

Abstract

Read online

The editors of Analytical Approaches to World Music are pleased to present the following set of invited responses to Andrew Killick’s article “Global Notation as a Tool for Cross-Cultural and Comparative Music Analysis.” While Andrew Killick has been developing global notation since 2016, the present article stems from his presentation at the Fifth International Conference on Analytical Approaches to World Music in Thessaloniki in 2018. The presentation generated lively discussion at the conference, and when Killick subsequently submitted the paper to the journal, one of the peer reviewers recommended publishing responses alongside the article. In compiling these responses, we have sought to include perspectives from scholars with a range of backgrounds and identities in terms of academic discipline, area of expertise, race, gender, age, and nationality. The set of responses does not fully live up to these goals insofar as the majority of respondents are men, are white, and are based in the US, Canada, or the UK. The fact that most of the women and Black, Asian, and Latinx scholars whom we invited were not able to spare the time to contribute responses may partly reflect the pervasive inequities within and beyond academia that have only been deepened by the ongoing public health crisis. In any case, our failure to attract a more diverse group of respondents should not reflect on the responses themselves, which offer thought-provoking and creative commentaries on the promise and challenges of Killick’s innovation to music notation, and we are grateful to all respondents for their contributions to the project. The responses are linked below in alphabetical order by author’s name.