Frontiers in Bioengineering and Biotechnology (Aug 2015)

Building better environmental risk assessments

  • Raymond eLayton,
  • Joe eSmith,
  • Phil eMacdonald,
  • Ramatha eLetchumanan,
  • Paul eKeese,
  • Martin eLema

DOI
https://doi.org/10.3389/fbioe.2015.00110
Journal volume & issue
Vol. 3

Abstract

Read online

Risk assessment is a reasoned, structured approach to address uncertainty based on scientific and technical evidence. It forms the foundation for regulatory decision making, which is bound by legislative and policy requirements, as well as the need for making timely decisions using available resources. In order to be most useful, environmental risk assessments (ERA) for genetically modified (GM) crops should provide consistent, reliable, and transparent results across all types of GM crops, traits, and environments. The assessments must also separate essential information from scientific or agronomic data of marginal relevance or value for evaluating risk and complete the assessment in a timely fashion. Challenges in conducting ERAs differ across regulatory systems – examples are presented from Canada, Malaysia, and Argentina. One challenge faced across the globe is the conduct of risk assessments with limited resources. This challenge can be overcome by clarifying risk concepts, placing greater emphasis on data critical to assess environmental risk (for example, phenotypic and plant performance data rather than molecular data), and adapting advances in risk analysis from other relevant disciplines.

Keywords