Non-Combat Use of Military Power: Stability Policing in Afghanistan and Iraq

Abstract

This comparative analysis examines the doctrine of stability policing, an innovative approach to the use of military force that goes beyond traditional combat missions. Stability policing operations are defined as activities aimed at the restoration of public order and the maintenance of law and order in conflict zones or post-conflict areas. Through comparative case studies of Afghanistan and Iraq, the main objective of the study is to explore the rationale, challenges, and consequences of the use of military personnel or military status law enforcement forces for stability policing operations. Bringing together these different conflict experiences, this analysis focuses on the strengths and weaknesses of stability policing operations as a doctrine and on its applicability in the future operational environment. The study also includes assessments of the effectiveness of this doctrine, which by its very nature requires a comprehensive and multifaceted approach to support post-conflict stability, ensure civil-military cooperation, and shape the contours of peace in contemporary complex environments.

Keywords

• stability policing
• iraq
• afghanistan
• law enforcement with military status
• use of non-combat military force