Types of EMG Textile Electrodes: A Comparative Study Using PCA

Abstract

Identifying a suitable textile electrode that would be durable and assist in recording high-quality bio-signal quality is crucial in the production of medical devices. Therefore, this study is aimed at comparing the time domain characteristics of silver-plated-polyamide-embroidered cotton (SPEC), copper-nickel-plated polyester (CNP), and stainless-steel-fabric (SSF) dry textile electromyography (EMG) electrodes through principal component analysis (PCA). The standard silver/silver chloride (Ag/AgCl) gel electrode was considered as the reference for all the test textile electrodes mentioned above. The EMG signal was measured by activation of the bicep and tibialis anterior muscles, and the time domain features such as root mean square (RMS) voltage, average rectified value (ARV) voltage, signal to noise ratio (SNR), kurtosis, and skewness were extracted from the EMG signal. The SSF electrode outperformed CNP and SPEC electrodes. Each textile electrode exhibited signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) values comparable to that of the standard electrode. The SNR values were 24.38 dB, 17.72 dB, 15.55 dB, and 13.30 dB for Ag/AgCl, SSF, CNP and SPEC electrodes, respectively. The performance of all the conductive textile electrodes was comparable to that of Ag/AgCl. However, the gel electrode required skin preparation and exhibited short-term stability, whereas, textile electrode materials were long-lasting and could be used for biological signal monitoring at home without the assistance of medical professionals.

Keywords

• stainless steel
• copper-nickel-plated polyester
• embroidery
• EMG signal analysis
• PCA