BMC Pulmonary Medicine (Nov 2023)

Doubts and concerns about COVID-19 uncertainties on imaging data, clinical score, and outcomes

  • Cosimo Nardi,
  • Andrea Magnini,
  • Linda Calistri,
  • Edoardo Cavigli,
  • Anna Julie Peired,
  • Vieri Rastrelli,
  • Edoardo Carlesi,
  • Giulia Zantonelli,
  • Olga Smorchkova,
  • Lorenzo Cinci,
  • Martina Orlandi,
  • Nicholas Landini,
  • Edoardo Berillo,
  • Chiara Lorini,
  • Jessica Mencarini,
  • Maria Grazia Colao,
  • Leonardo Gori,
  • Valentina Luzzi,
  • Chiara Lazzeri,
  • Elisa Cipriani,
  • Manuela Bonizzoli,
  • Filippo Pieralli,
  • Carlo Nozzoli,
  • Alessandro Morettini,
  • Federico Lavorini,
  • Alessandro Bartoloni,
  • Gian Maria Rossolini,
  • Marco Matucci-Cerinic,
  • Sara Tomassetti,
  • Stefano Colagrande

DOI
https://doi.org/10.1186/s12890-023-02763-3
Journal volume & issue
Vol. 23, no. 1
pp. 1 – 12

Abstract

Read online

Abstract Background COVID-19 is a pandemic disease affecting predominantly the respiratory apparatus with clinical manifestations ranging from asymptomatic to respiratory failure. Chest CT is a crucial tool in diagnosing and evaluating the severity of pulmonary involvement through dedicated scoring systems. Nonetheless, many questions regarding the relationship of radiologic and clinical features of the disease have emerged in multidisciplinary meetings. The aim of this retrospective study was to explore such relationship throughout an innovative and alternative approach. Materials and methods This study included 550 patients (range 25–98 years; 354 males, mean age 66.1; 196 females, mean age 70.9) hospitalized for COVID-19 with available radiological and clinical data between 1 March 2021 and 30 April 2022. Radiological data included CO-RADS, chest CT score, dominant pattern, and typical/atypical findings detected on CT examinations. Clinical data included clinical score and outcome. The relationship between such features was investigated through the development of the main four frequently asked questions summarizing the many issues arisen in multidisciplinary meetings, as follows 1) CO-RADS, chest CT score, clinical score, and outcomes; 2) the involvement of a specific lung lobe and outcomes; 3) dominant pattern/distribution and severity score for the same chest CT score; 4) additional factors and outcomes. Results 1) If CT was suggestive for COVID, a strong correlation between CT/clinical score and prognosis was found; 2) Middle lobe CT involvement was an unfavorable prognostic criterion; 3) If CT score 50%, crazy paving as dominant pattern leaded to a 15% increased death rate, stacked up against other patterns, thus almost doubling it; 4) Additional factors usually did not matter, but lymph-nodes and pleural effusion worsened prognosis. Conclusions This study outlined those radiological features of COVID-19 most relevant towards disease severity and outcome with an innovative approach.

Keywords