Automated Drugs Dispensing Systems in Hospitals: a Health Technology Assessment (HTA) Study Across Six European Countries

Abstract

Emanuela Foglia,1 Federica Asperti,1 Grazia Antonacci,2,3 Yogini H Jani,4 Elisabetta Garagiola,1 Daniele Bellavia,1 Lucrezia Ferrario1 1LIUC - University Cattaneo, Healthcare Datascience LAB, Castellanza, Varese, 21053, Italy; 2Department of Primary Care and Public Health, Imperial College London, National Institute of Health Research (NIHR) Applied Research Collaboration (ARC) Northwest London, London, UK; 3Business School, Centre for Health Economics and Policy Innovation (CHEPI), Imperial College London, London, UK; 4Centre for Medicines Optimisation Research and Education, University College London Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, London, UKCorrespondence: Elisabetta Garagiola, Healthcare Datascience Laboratory - HD LAB, LIUC-Università Cattaneo, Corso G. Matteotti, 22, Castellanza, VA, 21053, Italy, Tel [phone], Email [email protected]: Automated Drug Dispensing (ADD) systems are considered to be strategic hospital assets used to reduce errors and enhance economic and organizational sustainability. With regards to efficacy and safety, the literature evidence demonstrates the incremental benefits of centralised or decentralised systems compared to manual dispensing. Analyses about organisational and economic sustainability are still lacking and the present study aims to perform a Health Technology Assessment (HTA), producing multidimensional evidence on the use of ADD systems within hospitals.Methods: In 2023, a comprehensive HTA draws insights from healthcare professionals across six European nations: Italy, France, Germany, the Netherlands, the United Kingdom, and Belgium. This appraisal juxtaposed four drug dispensing scenarios: manual methods, centralized ADD systems, decentralized ADD systems, and integrated solutions employing cutting-edge technologies in both central pharmacies and wards. The study deployed an Activity-Based Costing approach that was combined with a cost-effectiveness and Budget Impact Analysis to evaluate economic impacts. Qualitative questionnaires were implemented to assess ethical, legal, organizational, safety, and efficacy aspects.Results: From a multidimensional perspective, healthcare professionals acknowledged ADD manifold advantages of ADD systems. From an organizational perspective and within a 12-month timeframe, transitioning to automation may face initial challenges that are attributed to potential resistance from professionals and significant investments. However, 36 months past its adoption, automation’s superiority over manual methods was recognized. Economically, savings burgeoned from +17.9% in UK to +26.6% in Belgian hospitals that adopted integrated systems in comparison to traditional manual approaches.Conclusion: Compared to traditional methods, implementing ADD systems could improve the logistic management of drug in the hospital setting, thereby enhancing safety and efficacy, streamlining the healthcare professionals’ workflow, and bolstering financial stability.Keywords: automated drug dispensing systems, HTA, economic impact, drug logistic management, efficiency

Keywords

• automated drug dispensing systems
• hta
• economic impact
• drug logistic management
• efficiency