Development and validation of an ama instrument for assessing the disease activity on the basis of constitutional features in Amavata (Rheumatoid Arthritis)

Abstract

Background: Rheumatoid Arthritis (RA), having a striking clinical resemblance to amavata in traditional Indian medicine (Ayurveda) presents an opportunity to look at disease from two different healthcare perspectives. This differential information may potentially supplement one system with the knowledge of the other for optimal application. This study is the first of its kind, where Ayurvedic concepts of amavata have been adopted to enhance the knowledge about RA where optimal care is still beyond the common reach. Objective: The study was conducted to develop and validate a novel ama score based upon constitutional features of ama as depicted in ayurvedic literature as a disease activity indicator in RA. Material and methods: The study was conducted in two parts comprising development and textual validation of the ama assessment instrument (AAI) followed by its clinical testing. AAI comprising ten items, was developed where each item was provided with a range of scores to offer the assessment close to the patient's observations. The score obtained through AAI was clinically and statistically tested on 79 RA/amavata patients randomly selected for validity and reliability. The score obtained through AAI was tested for its correlation with the DAS-28 score and ESR. Results: Ama Assessment Instrument could find a slight correlation with acute phase reactant ESR (r-value between ESR and AMA at baseline is 0.287, and at 1st, 2nd, and 3rd follow-up is 0.276, 0.276 and 0.160 respectively) and DAS-28 (The r value between DAS and AMA at baseline is 0.231, and at 1st, 2nd and 3rd follow up is 0.218, 0.201 and 0.247 respectively). It however emerged as an independent disease status marker since it could mark the changes in the study population on a time scale more precisely as compared to DAS -28 or ESR. When the ama values at different follow-ups were compared, a significant difference was observed consistent with disease activity marker catching constitutional and GI related domain of the patients. When reducing values of ama score were compared to overall improvements as reported by the patients, a similar trend was observed showing that a change in ama score is reflective of a change in disease status and the impact of the disease on the patient. Conclusion: This study provided a quantitative measure for the abstract concept of ama which could be used to mark the disease activity in amavata or RA. The change in ama based scores can be used to assess disease status and the intervention related benefits. The observations prompt for the possible inclusion of AAI in RA composite score to make it more dynamic in terms of disease activity identification in RA.

Keywords

• Disease activity score
• Rheumatoid arthritis
• Amavata
• Ayurveda