Ecological Indicators (Nov 2024)
Water quality patterns in at-risk fish habitat: Assessing frequency and cumulative duration of chloride guideline exceedance during early life stages of an endangered fish
Abstract
A comprehensive understanding of the impact of contaminants on organisms requires consideration of magnitude, duration, frequency, and life-history stage of exposure. Government guidelines provide a benchmark to evaluate exposure magnitude, but solely assessing magnitude does not consider duration and frequency of exposure. High-frequency sampling of data enables better integration of temporal patterns of potential environmental stressors and can inform research about habitat suitability. We develop and demonstrate an approach to examine temporal dynamics of abiotic conditions using high-frequency sampling data to assess water quality in the habitat of a Canadian federally listed endangered fish species, the Redside Dace (Clinostomus elongatus). Urban stressors, including chloride and non-point source pollutants, are considered contributing factors to the decline of Redside Dace in Canada. We collected and analyzed conductivity/chloride data from nine Redside Dace sites with varying degrees of upstream urbanization in the Greater Toronto Area to understand spatial and temporal variation in chloride exposure. Chloride loading in the region is largely driven by application of winter de-icing salt contributing to year-round elevated chloride concentrations. We highlight chloride patterns during critical early life stages of Redside Dace (spring spawning through summer; ‘non-salting season’), when sensitivity to stressors may be heightened. We assessed our data against the federal Canadian and American guidelines and found that at six out of nine sites, critical early life stages were exposed to chloride concentrations that exceeded the magnitude threshold of Canadian guidelines. We found instances of chronic duration threshold exceedance at six out of nine sites. Future research can leverage our approach to identify areas of concern where magnitude and duration thresholds are exceeded, and our results can be used to inform the duration of stressor exposure to critical life-history stages during ecologically relevant laboratory-based ecotoxicology studies. We emphasize that our approach can be used for any environmental parameter sampled with high frequency to better understand temporal regimes of ecological stressors.
