Indoor Environments (Oct 2024)
Influence of uncomfortable environmental conditions on odor detection thresholds for n-butanol determined with a dynamic dilution olfactometer and in room air
Abstract
Odor guide values (OGV) are used when a person is exposed to an odor in a room and complains about odor annoyance. OGV are derived from odor detection thresholds (ODT) measured under standard environmental conditions. The study question was whether uncomfortable environmental conditions alter odor perception and should therefore be considered when applying OGV. ODT for n-butanol were determined with an olfactometer and in room air. Twenty healthy, non-smoking volunteers (10 women/10 men, 19–50 years) were selected and trained compliant with the European Standard for Olfactometry EN 13725:2022. Standard conditions were an average temperature between 22 °C and 23 °C, warm light (2800 Kelvin), quiet fan noise (45 dB), 415 ppm carbon dioxide (CO2), and relative humidity between 34 % and 42 %. On each test day, one of five conditions was examined: high temperature (26°C), cold light (6500 Kelvin), traffic noise (70 dB with peaks up to 85 dB), 1000 ppm CO2 and 4000 ppm CO2. Comparability of log-transformed ODT values was assessed by Bland-Altman plot analysis. None of the five conditions systematically affected ODT, either when measured with an olfactometer or in room air. Compared to standard conditions (Limits of Agreement (± LoA) 1.03), the variability of ODT was higher at high temperature (± LoA 1.70) and traffic noise (± LoA 1.45), but not at cold light (± LoA 1.02), 1000 ppm CO2 (± LoA 0.87) or 4000 ppm CO2 (± LoA 0.93). The results show that OGV can be used in uncomfortable environmental conditions. However, because ODT were lower or higher in a few subjects at high temperatures and traffic noise, individual occupant’s perception of temperature and noise should always be considered when applying the OGV concept. Furthermore, the results confirm that the experimental determination of ODT should be performed under controlled and standardized environmental conditions.
