JSES International (Nov 2023)

High variability in what is considered important to report following instability surgery: a Delphi study among Dutch shoulder specialists

  • Lukas P.E. Verweij, MD,
  • Just A. van der Linde, MD, PhD,
  • Derek F.P. van Deurzen, MD, PhD,
  • Michel P.J. van den Bekerom, MD, PhD,
  • E.E.J. Raven,
  • M.P.J. van den Borne,
  • O.A.J. van der Meijden,
  • T.D.W. Alta,
  • R.N. Wessel,
  • A. van Noort,
  • T. Gosens,
  • Y.V. Kleinlugtenbelt,
  • T.D. Berendes,
  • H.C. van der Veen,
  • C. Visser,
  • O.F.O. Lambers Heerspink,
  • O. van der Meer,
  • I. Bonneux,
  • S. Floor,
  • D.P. van Oostveen

Journal volume & issue
Vol. 7, no. 6
pp. 2316 – 2320

Abstract

Read online

Background: Standardized reporting leads to high-quality data and can reduce administration time. The aim of this study was to (1) get an insight into the variability of what is considered important to report in the surgical report following shoulder instability surgery and (2) determine which elements should be included in the surgical report following shoulder instability surgery according to Dutch surgeons using a Delphi method. Methods: Dutch orthopedic shoulder surgeons were included in a panel for a Delphi study consisting of 3 rounds. Importance of the elements was rated on a 9-point Likert scale. High variability was defined as an element that received at least 1 score between 1 and 3 and 1 score between 7 and 9 in round 3. Consensus was defined as ≥80% of the panel giving a score of 7 or more. Results: Seventeen shoulder specialists completed all 3 rounds and identified a total of 82 elements for the arthroscopic Bankart repair and 60 for the open Latarjet. High variability was observed in 57 (70%) and 52 (87%) of the elements, respectively. After round 3, the panel reached consensus on 27 and 11 elements that should be mentioned in the surgical report following arthroscopic Bankart repair and open Latarjet. Conclusion: There is high variability in what shoulder specialists regard essential to report. Consensus was reached on 27 and 11 elements to be reported following arthroscopic Bankart repair and open Latarjet, respectively. Future studies on an international scale can further improve data collection and communication between specialists.

Keywords