Health Research Policy and Systems (Nov 2018)

Subjective judgements – no more, no less? A response to Malterud, Bjelland and Elvbakken

  • Atle Fretheim

DOI
https://doi.org/10.1186/s12961-018-0386-x
Journal volume & issue
Vol. 16, no. 1
pp. 1 – 2

Abstract

Read online

Abstract In 2016, three researchers published a report where they concluded that systematic reviews from my institution, the Norwegian Knowledge Centre for the Health Services, are of little use for health policy decision-making. Based on their reading of the conclusion section in 14 reports, they argue that our systematic reviews are not useful due to their lack of clear and conclusive findings. I have reviewed the same documents and I beg to differ. Unfortunately, the description of their methodological approach is both sparse and difficult to grasp, making it very hard to understand how they arrived at their conclusions.

Keywords