Forensic Science International: Reports (Jul 2021)
The pattern of genito-anal injuries in female sexual assault cases in Mumbai, India
Abstract
Background: The prevalence of genito-anal injuries in victims of sexual assault depends on several factors. Forensic examination, documentation of injuries and preparing report thus becomes challenging for healthcare providers as the presence or absence of injuries aids in the subsequent laying of charges against the accused. This paper aims to determine the pattern of genito-anal injuries and factors associated with the laying of charges against the accused. Methods: A cross-sectional study of victims of sexual assault (n = 440) was conducted between 2014 and 2017 in a specialized tertiary care center in a Metropolitan city in India. The results were expressed as proportion and percentage. Chi-squared test was used to analyse data using SPSS version 23.0. Results: There was no statistically significant association between reporting within 72 h of sexual assault and the arrest of the accused. Vaginal and anal bleeding were present in 4.1% cases and 2.7% cases respectively. Genital and anal injuries were present only in 30.9% of cases. The most common genito-anal injury was laceration (72.08%). Posterior fourchette injury (most common site) was present in 27.94% of cases. Extra genital injuries were found in 24.09% of victims. The most common extra genital injury was abrasion (26.42%). Intoxicants were found in the blood of 4.8% of victims and spermatozoa/semen was found in swabs from 3.6% of victims. In this study 25.9% of perpetrators were arrested, out of which 84.37% of adult victim’s cases and 94.23% of minor ( 0.05) and were dropped from the model. The odds ratio (OR) for charge-laying associated with the age of the victim 18 years age and 18 years of age did not appear to have any influence over the arrest. A notable finding was a high proportion (75.51% in 18 years) of cases where an arrest was effected in adults and child sexual assault cases where no injuries were described. Conclusion: This study shows the pattern of genito-anal injuries and factors associated with the laying of charges in sexual assault cases in a developing country. It should be noted that most of those exposed to sexual assault do not have visible genito-anal injuries. We report that age is significantly associated with the presence of genito-anal injuries. However, it is important to note that the presence of injuries does not prove rape, neither its absence disproves the act. The information gathered by a meticulous forensic examination does make a difference in the legal outcome for cases of sexual assault.
