Gibbs Free Energy and Enthalpy–Entropy Compensation in Protein–Ligand Interactions

Abstract

The thermodynamics of protein–ligand interactions seems to be associated with a narrow range of Gibbs free energy. As a consequence, a linear enthalpy–entropy relationship showing an apparent enthalpy–entropy compensation (EEC) is frequently associated with protein–ligand interactions. When looking for the most negative values of ∆H to gain affinity, the entropy compensation gives rise to a barely noticeable increase in affinity, therefore negatively affecting the design and discovery of new and more efficient drugs capable of binding protein targets with a higher affinity. Originally attributed to experimental errors, compensation between ∆H and T∆S values is an observable fact, although its molecular origin has remained obscure and controversial. The thermodynamic parameters of a protein–ligand interaction can be interpreted in terms of the changes in molecular weak interactions as well as in vibrational, rotational, and translational energy levels. However, a molecular explanation to an EEC rendering a linear enthalpy–entropy relationship is still lacking. Herein, we show the results of a data search of ∆G values of 3025 protein–ligand interactions and 2558 “in vivo” ligand concentrations from the Protein Data Bank database and the Metabolome Database (2020). These results suggest that the EEC may be plausibly explained as a consequence of the narrow range of ∆G associated with protein–ligand interactions. The Gaussian distribution of the ∆G values matches very well with that of ligands. These results suggest the hypothesis that the set of ∆G values for the protein–ligand interactions is the result of the evolution of proteins. The conformation versatility of present proteins and the exchange of thousands (even millions) of minute amounts of energy with the environment may have functioned as a homeostatic mechanism to make the ∆G of proteins adaptive to changes in the availability of ligands and therefore achieve the maximum regulatory capacity of the protein function. Finally, plausible strategies to avoid the EEC consequences are suggested.

Keywords

• enthalpy–entropy compensation
• protein ligand interactions
• thermodynamic parameters