During the diagnostic work-up in oncology, it is exceedingly rare to assume a concomitant presence of two cancers, a benign one and a malignant one, in a single patient. A 61-year-old man was admitted to the cardiology department for cardiac evaluation prior to planned radical treatment of non-small cell (NSCLC) left lung cancer (cT3N1M0). Echocardiography revealed a prominent, unpedunculated structure, measuring 17 × 14 mm, located in the left atrium (LA) near the fossa ovalis. The tumor was confirmed via cardiac magnetic resonance (CMR) imaging, which showed the radiological features of an atrial myxoma. The patient consulted with the Cardiac Surgery Department and was deemed ineligible for surgical treatment of a lesion with mucinous features; thus, no definitive histopathologic confirmation of the tumor present was possible. He was then successfully treated with radical radiochemotherapy and immunotherapy. During the 2-year follow-up, regular echocardiography and CMR were performed, which documented a stable LA tumor size.