Transplantation Direct (Aug 2021)

HLA Antibody Incompatible Renal Transplantation: Long-term Outcomes Similar to Deceased Donor Transplantation

  • Nithya Krishnan, MD, FRCP,
  • Aisha Abimbola, MSc,
  • Nandhini Machan, MSc,
  • Sunil Daga, PhD, FRCP,
  • Kishore Gopalakrishnan, MBBS, FRCPath,
  • ForTai Lam, MD, FRCS,
  • LamChin Tan, MD, FRCS,
  • Habib Kashi, MD, FRCS,
  • Christopher Imray, MD, FRCS,
  • Daniel Zehnder, PhD, FRCP,
  • Claire Collins, BSc,
  • Rebecca Curtis, BSc,
  • Robert Higgins, MD, FRCP,
  • Natasha Khovanova, PhD,
  • David Briggs, PhD

DOI
https://doi.org/10.1097/TXD.0000000000001183
Journal volume & issue
Vol. 7, no. 8
p. e732

Abstract

Read online

Background. HLA incompatible renal transplantation still remains one of best therapeutic options for a subgroup of patients who are highly sensitized and difficult to match but not much is known about its long-term graft and patient survival. Methods. One hundred thirty-four HLA incompatible renal transplantation patients from 2003 to 2018 with a median follow of 6.93 y were analyzed retrospectively to estimate patient and graft survivals. Outcomes were compared with groups defined by baseline crossmatch status and the type and timings of rejection episodes. Results. The overall patient survival was 95%, 90%, and 81%; and graft survival was 95%, 85%, and 70% at 1, 5, and 10 y, respectively. This was similar to the first-time deceased donor transplant cohort. The graft survival for pretreatment cytotoxic-dependent crossmatch (CDC) positive crossmatch group was significantly low at 83%, 64%, and 40% at 1, 5, and 10 y, respectively, compared with other groups (Bead/CDC, P = 0.007; CDC/Flow, P = 0.001; and microbead assay/flow cytometry crossmatch, P = 0.837), although those with a low CDC titer (<1 in 2) have comparable outcomes to the CDC negative group. Female patients in general fared worse in both patient and graft survival outcomes in each of the 3 groups based on pretreatment crossmatch, although this did not reach statistical significance. Antibody-mediated rejection was the most frequent type of rejection with significant decline in graft survival by 10 y when compared with no rejection (P < 0.001). Rejection that occurred or continued to occur after the first 2 wk of transplantation caused a significant reduction in graft survivals (P < 0.001), whereas good outcomes were seen in those with a single early rejection episode. Conclusions. One-, 5-, and 10-y HLA incompatible graft and patient survival is comparable to deceased donor transplantation and can be further improved by excluding high-CDC titer cases. Antibody-positive female patients show worse long-term survival. Resolution of early rejection is associated with good long-term graft survival.