Quantifying Perception of Security Through Social Media and Its Relationship With Crime

Abstract

The perception of security refers to the subjective evaluation of risks related to security events and the magnitude of their consequences. Negative perceptions have severe implications in society. These feelings are commonly quantified by citizen’s surveys, which are time-consuming and do not adapt well to the changing dynamics linked to security. Recently, Twitter social network emerged as an alternative to quantify some of these feelings dynamically. However, most of these approaches focused on counting the amount of content related to crime, which is only one of the relevant factors determining the perception of security. This work introduces a novel model for quantifying the Perception of Security on Twitter based on sentiment analysis and studies its relationship with actual crime. The model relies on an automatic strategy for filtering content related to security based on a support vector machine classifier and quantifying the sentiment in the posts using a multinomial naive Bayes classifier. This model studied more than 1.700.000 tweets in Bogotá, collected during more than one year (March 18 of 2019 - April 28 of 2020). Results suggest that machine learning-based approaches may outperform previous security content filtering strategies by 21% in F1-score and provide quantifications on the sentiments of about 40% on accuracy. Trained models were used to provide daily estimates of perception of security, which are different from those captured by counting the number of posts related to security. Furthermore, the associations between perceptions and actual crimes exhibited monthly variations and showed that in some months, perceptions were more related to robbery, a crime with high incidence in the city. These results may help decision-makers devise strategies to reduce the impact of the negative perception on citizens.

Keywords

• Security
• crime
• quantification of perception of security
• sentiment analysis
• social media content
• opinion dynamics