Evaluation of Machine Learning Algorithms in Network-Based Intrusion Detection Using Progressive Dataset

Abstract

Cybersecurity has become one of the focuses of organisations. The number of cyberattacks keeps increasing as Internet usage continues to grow. As new types of cyberattacks continue to emerge, researchers focus on developing machine learning (ML)-based intrusion detection systems (IDS) to detect zero-day attacks. They usually remove some or all attack samples from the training dataset and only include them in the testing dataset when evaluating the performance. This method may detect unknown attacks; however, it does not reflect the long-term performance of the IDS as it only shows the changes in the type of attacks. In this work, we focused on evaluating the long-term performance of ML-based IDS. To achieve this goal, we proposed evaluating the ML-based IDS using a dataset created later than the training dataset. The proposed method can better assess the long-term performance as the testing dataset reflects the changes in the attack type and network infrastructure changes over time. We have implemented six of the most popular ML models, including decision tree (DT), random forest (RF), support vector machine (SVM), naïve Bayes (NB), artificial neural network (ANN), and deep neural network (DNN). These models are trained and tested with a pair of datasets with symmetrical classes. Our experiments using the CIC-IDS2017 and the CSE-CIC-IDS2018 datasets show that SVM and ANN are most resistant to overfitting. Our experiments also indicate that DT and RF suffer the most from overfitting, although they perform well on the training dataset. On the other hand, our experiments using the LUFlow dataset have shown that all models can perform well when the difference between the training and testing datasets is small.

Keywords

• intrusion detection
• machine learning
• deep learning
• cybersecurity