Implications of Pulse Frequency in Terrestrial Laser Scanning on Forest Point Cloud Quality and Individual Tree Structural Metrics

Abstract

Terrestrial laser scanning (TLS) provides highly detailed 3D information of forest environments but is limited to small spatial scales, as data collection is time consuming compared to other remote sensing techniques. Furthermore, TLS data collection is heavily dependent on wind conditions, as the movement of trees negatively impacts the acquired data. Hardware advancements resulting in faster data acquisition times have the potential to be valuable in upscaling efforts but might impact overall data quality. In this study, we investigated the impact of the pulse repetition rate (PRR), or pulse frequency, which is the number of laser pulses emitted per second by the scanner. Increasing the PRR reduces the scan time required for a single scan but decreases the power (amplitude) of the emitted laser pulses commensurately. This trade-off could potentially impact the quality of the acquired data. We used a RIEGL VZ400i laser scanner to test the impact of different PRR settings on the point cloud quality and derived tree structural metrics from individual tree point clouds (diameter, tree height, crown projected area) as well as quantitative structure models (total branch length, tree volume). We investigated this impact across five field plots of different forest complexity and canopy density for three different PRR settings (300, 600 and 1200 kHz). The scan time for a single scan was 180, 90 and 45 s for 300, 600 and 1200 kHz, respectively. Differences among the raw acquired scans from different PRR replicates were largely removed by several necessary data processing steps, notably the removal of uncertain points with a low reflectance attribute. We found strong agreement between the individual tree structural metrics derived from each of the PRR replicates, independent of the forest complexity. This was the case for both point cloud-based metrics and those derived from quantitative structural models (QSMs). The results demonstrate that the PRR in high-end TLS instruments can be increased for data collection with negligible impact on a selection of derived structural metrics that are commonly used in the context of aboveground biomass estimation.

Keywords

• terrestrial laser scanning
• pulse repetition rate
• point clouds