Sequência: Estudos Juridicos e Politicos (Dec 2021)

The Inter-American Rule of Law in South American constitutionalism

  • Carolina Machado Cyrillo da Silva,
  • Édgar Hérnan Fuentes-Contreras,
  • Siddharta Legale

DOI
https://doi.org/10.5007/2177-7055.2021.e83437
Journal volume & issue
Vol. 42, no. 88

Abstract

Read online

The objective of this text is to present the modification of the conception of Rule of Law in the South America constitutionalism, from the dialogue and synergy between the Inter-American System of Human Rights and the new constitutions that emerged after dictatorships, authoritarian regimes, and internal wars, taking Operation Condor as a clandestine inter-American system or as unconventional status quo. We problematize how it is possible to speak of "Inter-American Rule of Law", which means the reconstruction of that State compatible with the ACHR in the Legislative, Executive and Judiciary spheres, as well the conventionality control and the standards emanating from the IACourtHR to laws, public policies, and national court decisions. Therefore, we defend the thesis that this dialogue can be the key to access the engine room of the constitutions, with the pro persona principle. The methodology used was a theoretical and normative approach, from a hypothetical deductive perspective and prioritizing as sources the bibliography and the caselaw of the IACourtHR.

Keywords