Education Policy Analysis Archives (Aug 2003)

Comments on Weiner, Resnick and Scientific Debate

  • Jonathan Goodman

Journal volume & issue
Vol. 11
p. 29

Abstract

Read online

Lois Weiner (2003) and Lauren Resnick (2003) have advanced substantially different views of the success of the reforms undertaken by Community School District Two (CSD2) in New York city. Weiner's position vis a vis District Two has probably conferred a greater measure of objectivity to her views. Criticisms of scholarly work, even when sharply worded, are neither personal nor unscientific; indeed they are quite common in all the sciences.