SAPEVO-PC: Integrating Multi-Criteria Decision-Making and Machine Learning to Evaluate Navy Ships

Abstract

The selection of a navy ship is essential to guarantee a country’s sovereignty, deterrence capabilities, and national security, especially in the face of possible conflicts and diplomatic instability. This paper proposes the integration of concepts related to multi-criteria decision making (MCDM) methodology and machine learning, creating the Simple Aggregation of Preferences Expressed by Ordinal Vectors—Principal Components (SAPEVO-PC) method. The proposed method proposes an evolution of the SAPEVO family, allowing the inclusion of qualitative preferences, and adds concepts from Principal Component Analysis (PCA), aiming to simplify the decision-making process, maintaining precision and reliability. We carried out a case study analyzing 32 warships and ten quantitative criteria, demonstrating the practical application and effectiveness of the method. The generated rankings reflected both subjective perceptions and the quantitative performance data of each ship. This innovative integration of qualitative data with a quantitative machine learning algorithm ensures comprehensive and robust analyses, facilitating informed and strategic decisions. The results showed a high degree of consistency and reliability, with the top and bottom rankings remaining stable across different decision-makers’ perspectives. This study highlights the potential of SAPEVO-PC to improve decision-making efficiency in complex, multi-criteria environments, contributing to the field of marine science.

Keywords

• SAPEVO-PC
• machine learning
• marine science
• operations research
• multi-criteria