“Europe Is No Longer Europe”: Montaging Borderlands of Help for a Radical Politics of Place

Abstract

In this paper, we position the societal expectation of the ‘grateful refugee’ in the larger European script of placing migrant help and integration. We ask how might we re-imagine geographies of migrant ‘help’ so as to break with the dominant ontologies of places as sites embedded within the nation-state and the accompanying relations of power which displace the migrant in a perpetual penumbra of gratefulness? By montaging a series of contrapuntal vignettes of borderlands producing Europe, we examine the moral geographies of help and debt and how geographical imaginations of place and place-identities of practices of refugee-help today are entangled with mid-20th century wartime aid. Drawing inspiration from the negritude movement, we argue that such ‘untimely articulations’ produce ‘sites of décalage’ where Europe (as manifesting in such entangled moral geo-histories of help) is no longer Europe, suggesting an initial vocabulary for a radical politics of place.

Keywords

• politics of place
• help
• montage
• gratefulness
• europe