MedEdPublish (May 2021)
Empowering Medical Students to Respond to Discriminatory Comments from Patients: A Just-in-Time Training Method
Abstract
Physicians in training may experience harassment and discrimination from supervisors, consultants, colleagues, or patients and families. Instances of discrimination towards students may impact students’ self-esteem, self-efficacy, and ultimately performance. In this particular time, many institutions are looking to enhance their curriculum regarding bias. More tools are needed to help students feel empowered to respond professionally when they encounter challenging situations. This study was designed to assess the impact of a training intervention in addressing biased patient statements. The training was strategically placed prior to clinical interactions. The authors’ intention was to present discriminatory statements by patients as one of the many difficult clinical situations that students are being trained to navigate. The authors developed a clinical rubric for decision-making in flowchart style to mimic the decision trees used in diagnostic or treatment decisions. They then created a workshop to help learners use the flowsheet. The workshop was delivered to third-year medical students as part of “Junior Bootcamp,” a day-long session of events to orient students to the clinical experiences of the M3 year. The workshop was delivered in the summer of 2019. Respondents indicated that they were more likely to be able to appropriately respond to discriminatory comments after completing the workshop. They also felt that they were more likely to be able to engage in respectful dialogue with a patient and to debrief with a faculty member. Fewer participants felt that they were likely to use the flowchart. Findings indicate that the workshop was useful to participants. It may be especially useful to educators dealing with the COVID pandemic because it is scalable and easily delivered remotely. Further studies are needed to determine if introducing this topic in the clinical years of medical school leads to improved skill in addressing instances of bias that come from patients and families.
