There is not much known on the stability of plasticized polymeric sensor membranes against ionizing radiation. While recent studies have indicated the applicability of potentiometric sensors with such membranes for quantification of actinides and lanthanides in spent nuclear fuel reprocessing solutions, the real industrial application of such sensors will require their stability in ionizing radiation fields. The present study explores this problem and evaluates the stability of potentiometric sensitivity towards lanthanides and actinides for a variety of plasticized polymeric membranes based on different neutral ligands. We demonstrate that most of the studied sensor compositions retain their sensitivity up to 50–100 kGy of the absorbed gamma radiation dose. The higher doses lead to the gradual loss of sensitivity due to the radiolysis of ligands and a polymer membrane matrix as confirmed by electrochemical impedance and nuclear magnetic resonance studies.