A multi-center retrospective comparative study of third generation Ceramic-on- Ceramic total hip arthroplasty in patients younger than 45 years with or without the sandwich liner: A ten-year minimum

Abstract

Background Ceramic-on-ceramic couplings are attractive alternative bearing surfaces that have been reported to eliminate or reduce problems related to polyethylene wear debris. However, the material in THA still remains one of the major concerns about the risk of fracture, due to its brittleness. Objective The present study aims at reporting the fracture rate of a series of ceramic-on-ceramic THAs with use of the sandwich liner combined with a ceramic femoral head, and attempt to detect the relative risk factors, possible cause and assesse the medium-term clinical results. Methods We retrospectively evaluated 282 patients (300 hips) with use of the sandwich liner ceramic-on-ceramic THA between 2001 and 2009 at three-centers. Patient assessment was based on demographic factors, including age, weight, gender and body-mass index. All patients were evaluated clinically and radio-graphically or computed tomography in consideration of dislocation, osteolysis, periprosthetic fracture, infection, loosening and implant fracture. Results five ceramic sandwich liners fracture (1.7%) were observed at an average of 7.3 years follow-up. These factors were irrelevant to the ceramic liner fracture, including age ( p = 0.205), weight ( p = 0.241), gender ( p = 0.553), body-mass index ( p = 0.736), inclination ( p = 0.727), and anteversion ( p = 0.606). The overall survival was 91.4% at 12 years with revision as the endpoint. Other complications included dislocation in two, perprosthetic fracture in two and osteolysis in eight hips. No hip had aseptic loosening of the implants was seen. Conclusions We found that the sandwich liner may be lead to a high rate of alumina fracture and osteolysis. We have discontinued the use of sandwich liner with THA since 2009.