Characterization and Applicability of a Bone Spheroid Model for the Evaluation of Cytocompatibility of Bone Substitutes

Abstract

In vitro cell-based tests are an important preclinical step for the safety assessment of biomaterials and drugs. Three-dimensional cell culture models (3D) may improve the limitations of the usual 2D models, as they better simulate a physiological environment. This work describes the characterization of a 3D spheroid model of MC3T3-E1 murine preosteoblasts for the testing of bone-substitute materials and investigates its adequacy to some of the most employed cell viability tests. The spheroids presented structural stability for 28 days in culture, with a regular spheroidal aspect, compact surface, and dense inner structure, with high potential for mineralization, but a time-dependent reduction in size. The use of colorimetric tests (MTT, XTT, and NRU) did not achieve satisfactory optical densities and did not correlate with cell density in the 3D model, as the aggregates remain strongly stained even after dye extraction steps. On the other hand, the LDH test achieved appropriate optical density and a high correlation with cell density (r2 = 0.77) and identified a dose–response for a well-known cytotoxic polymer (latex), while no toxicity was identified for biocompatible PLA wires. These results indicate that material testing with 3D bone cell models requires a careful choice of test methods and parameters.

Keywords

• cell culture
• bone substitute
• biomaterials
• osteoblasts