Arthroplasty Today (Aug 2024)
Reversal of the Halo Effect: Prolonged Participation in Comprehensive Care for Joint Replacement Negatively Impacts Revision Metrics
Abstract
Background: The downstream regional effect of the Comprehensive Care for Joint Replacement (CJR) program on care pathway-adjacent patients, including revision arthroplasty patients, is poorly understood. Prior studies have demonstrated that care pathways targeting primary total joint arthroplasty may produce a halo effect, impacting more complex patients with parallel care pathways. However, neither the effect of regional referral changes from CJR nor the durability of these positive changes with prolonged bundle participation has been assessed. Methods: Blinded data were pulled from electronic medical records. Primary analyses focused on the effect of CJR participation from 2015 (baseline) to 2020 (final participation year) at a tertiary care safety-net hospital. Patient demographics were evaluated using multivariate analysis of variance and chi-square calculations between procedure types over time. Results: Patients who underwent revision total knee arthroplasty (N = 376) and revision total hip arthroplasty (N = 482) were included. More patients moved through the revision-care pathway over the participation period, with volume increasing by 42% over time. Patients became more medically complex: the Charlson comorbidity index increased from 3.91 to 4.65 (P = .01). The mean length of stay decreased from 5.14 days to 4.50 days (P = .03), but the all-cause complication (8.3%-15.2%; P = .02) and readmission rates (13.6%-16.6%; P = .19) increased over time. Conclusions: Despite care pathway improvements over 5 years of CJR participation, revision patients did not display clear benefits in quality metrics but demonstrated a considerable increase in volume and medical complexity over time. The care of these patients may supersede even thoughtfully implemented care pathways, especially when referral burden increases, as may be prone to happen in regional, financial risk-conferring value-based programs. Understanding the impact of mandatory bundled payment programs like CJR on the care of arthroplasty patients regionally will be essential as value-based programs evolve.
