Large variations between NICU nurses in predicting nasogastric tube insertion length in a mannequin study

Abstract

Aim: To evaluate the inter- and intraindividual variation of predicted nasogastric tube insertion lengths by nurses working in two neonatal intensive care units in the Netherlands, using a mannequin model. Methods: A total of 110 nurses (55 nurses from Center A and 55 from Center B) were asked to predict the nasogastric tube insertion length on a neonatal mannequin. We evaluated the length and prediction method used by the nurses. We also estimated the number of tubes that would have correctly been placed in the stomach of a neonate according to the seize of the mannequin. Results: The mean predicted insertion length of the nasogastric tube was 30.0 cm with an interindividual variation of 12 cm (range 24–36 cm). The mean intraindividual variation was 0.75 cm. The two centers used two different prediction methods in their local guidelines, but overall at least 6 different methods were used by the nurses. We estimated that 77% (85/110) of the tubes would have ended in the body of the mannequins stomach, while 10% (11/110) would have ended in the esophagus and 13% (14/110) would have ended against the stomach lining or in the duodenum. Conclusion: Nurses in two neonatal intensive care units used many different methods which lead to a large interindividual variation in predicted insertion lengths of the nasogastric tubes. Regular evaluations using this mannequin model could lead to more uniformity and reduce the risk of tube misplacement in neonates.

Keywords

• Nurses
• Nasogastric tube
• Neonates
• Interindividual variation
• Mannequin study