Comparing the Performance of Hydrocyclones and High-Frequency Screens in an Industrial Grinding Circuit: Part I—Size Separation Assessments

Abstract

Industrial ball milling circuits usually include hydrocyclones in a closed configuration to achieve a specified grinding size. Although hydrocyclones are relatively simple to operate, their classification performance is generally low, leading to significant fines recirculation within the circuit, consequently overgrinding the product. Conversely, high-frequency screening potentially shows a relatively higher separation efficiency, as the entrainment of fines to the coarse product is significantly reduced. The present work compares the performance of hydrocyclones—HC and high-frequency screens—HFS based on four surveys conducted in Nexa’s Vazante Zinc ore industrial grinding circuit in Vazante, Brazil, which processes zinc silicate ore. The comparisons included the partition of solids, water split, and particle size distributions. Whiten’s partition curve model was adopted to obtain the selected performance parameters through mass balancing the experimental data. The industrial surveys comprised three different size separation configurations, i.e., HC-Only, HFS-Only, and a combined HC-HFS setup. In all cases, the assessments consistently indicated higher separation performances with HFS compared to the HC operation. The final product associated with the HC+HFS configuration showed a narrower size distribution around the grinding size.

Keywords

• high-frequency screening
• hydrocyclones
• partition curve
• industrial grinding circuit