MedEdPublish (May 2018)
Using MMI Comments for Medical School Admissions Decision-Making
Abstract
Introduction Multiple mini-interview (MMI) comments can help to reveal an underlying personality or behavioral flaw that the numerical scores are not designed to illustrate. The importance of the comments provided by interviewers has not been documented in the literature. This study sought to examine whether MMI comments influenced admission committee decision-making. Methods Five thousand de-identified interview comments from a subset of 625 medical school applicants were reviewed by study raters who followed a rubric that outlined scoring assignments based upon the number of positive and negative statements made by MMI interviewers. The presence of extremely negative MMI comments was also evaluated. Results MMI score strongly correlated with MMI comment score assigned by the raters and contributed to overall committee score and decision for acceptance or rejection to medical school. The presence of one negative outlier comment score alone did not impact committee score or acceptance; however, when extremely negative attributes were identified by study raters within an outlier comment, this was associated with a reduction of final committee score and higher incidence of rejection. Conclusions A strong correlation existed between the MMI comments and overall MMI score. Both MMI comments and MMI scores predict acceptance to medical school. The additional value of the MMI comments lies in the extremely negative outlier comments.
