Identifying suitable indicators to measure ecological condition of rocky reef ecosystems in South Africa

Abstract

Baseline data for reference conditions are needed to determine the impacts of human pressures on the structure and functioning of marine ecosystems. However, baseline data are seldom available, and a comprehensive understanding of what good ecological condition is or how to measure it is often lacking. In the absence of true baselines, well established and effective marine protected areas (MPAs) can be used to approximate reference conditions. Thus, the aim of this study was to use effective no-take MPAs to identify suitable indicators that can be used for condition assessments of rocky reefs in South Africa. To achieve this, we tested the response of two types of metrics (compositional and size-based), using in situ fish and benthic community data, to three levels of human pressures in two ecoregions in South Africa. Results showed that traditionally-used structural metrics, such as total abundance or species richness, were less responsive than size-based metrics, including total biomass, average length and proportion of mature fish. Rocky reef ecosystems exposed to low anthropogenic pressure were characterised by a higher biomass, average length and proportion of mature and large (>30 cm) fish than reefs with moderate and high pressures. Benthic communities appeared more resilient than fish communities to the typical human pressures in the study region. Overall, the greatest effect of pressure was observed in the heavily impacted sub-tropical Natal Shelf Ecoregion, while rocky reefs in the warm-temperate Agulhas Shelf Ecoregion appeared to be in better condition than expected. This study identified assemblage patterns and indicators that appeared responsive and sensitive to different levels of human pressure, which can be used to infer good and poor ecological condition of rocky reef ecosystems. These results indicate which species (e.g., target species) and traits (e.g., size) are most vulnerable to local human pressures and will be suitable for condition assessments.

Keywords

• Fish metrics
• Benthic community metrics
• Reference conditions
• Size-based indicators
• Reef ecosystems
• Stereo-BRUVs