Optic pathway gliomas in children carry significant morbidity and therapeutic challenges. For the subgroup of pre-chiasmatic gliomas, intraorbital and intradural resection is a curative option after blindness. We present a two-center cohort using different surgical approaches. A retrospective analysis was performed, including 10 children. Mean age at surgery was 6.8 years. Interval between diagnosis and surgery was 1–74 (mean 24 ± 5.5, median 10) months. Indications for surgery were exophthalmos, pain, tumor progression, or a combination. Eight patients underwent an extradural trans-orbital-roof approach to resect the intra-orbital tumor, including the optic canal part plus intradural pre-chiasmatic resection. Gross total resection was achieved in 7/8, and none had a recurrence. One residual behind the bulbus showed progression, treated by chemotherapy. In two patients, a combined supra-orbital mini-craniotomy plus orbital frame osteotomy was used for intraorbital tumor resection + intradural pre-chiasmatic dissection. In these two patients, remnants of the optic nerve within the optic canal remained stable. No patient had a chiasmatic functional affection nor permanent oculomotor deficits. In selected patients, a surgical resection from bulb to chiasm ± removal of optic canal tumor was safe without long-term sequela and with an excellent cosmetic result. Surgery normalizes exophthalmos and provides an effective tumor control.