NeuroImage: Clinical (Jan 2022)
Assessment of intraoperative diffusion EPI distortion and its impact on estimation of supratentorial white matter tract positions in pediatric epilepsy surgery
Abstract
The effectiveness of correcting diffusion Echo Planar Imaging (EPI) distortion and its impact on tractography reconstruction have not been adequately investigated in the intraoperative MRI setting, particularly for High Angular Resolution Diffusion Imaging (HARDI) acquisition. In this study, we evaluated the effectiveness of EPI distortion correction using 27 legacy intraoperative HARDI datasets over two consecutive surgical time points, acquired without reverse phase-encoded data, from 17 children who underwent epilepsy surgery at our institution. The data was processed with EPI distortion correction using the Synb0-Disco technique (Schilling et al., 2019) and without distortion correction. The corrected and uncorrected b0 diffusion-weighted images (DWI) were first compared visually. The mutual information indices between the original T1-weighted images and the fractional anisotropy images derived from corrected and uncorrected DWI were used to quantify the effect of distortion correction. Sixty-four white matter tracts were segmented from each dataset, using a deep-learning based automated tractography algorithm for the purpose of a standardized and unbiased evaluation. Displacement was calculated between tracts generated before and after distortion correction. The tracts were grouped based on their principal morphological orientations to investigate whether the effects of EPI distortion vary with tract orientation. Group differences in tract distortion were investigated both globally, and regionally with respect to proximity to the resecting lesion in the operative hemisphere. Qualitatively, we observed notable improvement in the corrected diffusion images, over the typically affected brain regions near skull-base air sinuses, and correction of additional distortion unique to intraoperative open cranium images, particularly over the resection site. This improvement was supported quantitatively, as mutual information indices between the FA and T1-weighted images were significantly greater after the correction, compared to before the correction. Maximum tract displacement between the corrected and uncorrected data, was in the range of 7.5 to 10.0 mm, a magnitude that would challenge the safety resection margin typically tolerated for tractography-informed surgical guidance. This was particularly relevant for tracts oriented partially or fully in-line with the acquired diffusion phase-encoded direction. Portions of these tracts passing close to the resection site demonstrated significantly greater magnitude of displacement, compared to portions of tracts remote from the resection site in the operative hemisphere. Our findings have direct clinical implication on the accuracy of intraoperative tractography-informed image guidance and emphasize the need to develop a distortion correction technique with feasible intraoperative processing time.
