Randomised Controlled Trial of Self-Affirmation Intervention on Students’ Academic Performance: Promising Impacts on Students from Migrant Hukou Status

Abstract

Jilong Yang,1,* Yue Zhao,2,* Yuexin Ji,2 Jiaxin Ma,2 Lanyu Li,2 Xiaoyong Hu2 1The Open University of Guangdong, Guangdong Polytechnic Institute, Guangzhou, Guangdong, 510091, People’s Republic of China; 2Faculty of Psychology, Southwest University, Chongqing, 400715, People’s Republic of China*These authors contributed equally to this workCorrespondence: Xiaoyong Hu, Faculty of Psychology, Southwest University, 2 Tiansheng Road, Chongqing, 400715, People’s Republic of China, Tel [phone], Email [email protected]: Drawing from the sociocultural-self model, this study aims to examine the influence of self-affirmation on the academic outcomes of lower-class migrant students, as well as the psychological mechanism underlying this phenomenon.Patients and Methods: A field experiment was conducted at a comprehensive secondary school in the southern region of China. Our study sample comprised 1534 immigrant students from diverse regions across the country, with an average proportion of 59.6% of students registered with a rural hukou. The hukou system plays a pivotal role in measuring social class in China, thus it was used as a proxy for lower and higher social class, with rural hukou students considered to be lower-class and urban hukou students considered to be higher-class. Prior to the English test, students in the self-affirmed group were engaged in a brief writing exercise that focused on their core values, whereas the control group wrote about a neutral topic.Results: The primary outcome of interest was the effect of self-affirmation on English test scores, whereas the secondary outcome was the students’ survey stereotype threat. The results exhibit that self-affirmation more significantly improved the English test performance of lower-class students compared to higher-class students, and this positive effect was mediated by reducing stereotype threat.Conclusion: Our findings unravel the impact of self-affirmation on the academic performance of migrant students from different social classes and signify the mediating role of stereotype threat in this process. The present study extends previous findings to students from immigrant families in the Chinese cultural context, and these findings demonstrate that self-affirmation can constitute a promising intervention for stereotype threat and achievement gaps due to social class differences in immigrant family groups. Considering that this intervention takes only about 15 minutes of time, entails almost zero cost, does no harm, and that it focuses on disadvantaged immigrant students, it may provide valuable insights for educational policies to be implemented in a new type of migrant city such as Shenzhen.Keywords: social class, self-affirmation, stereotype threat, academic performance

Keywords

• social class
• self-affirmation
• stereotype threat
• academic performance