Minimally Modified HIV-1 Infection of Macaques: Development, Utility, and Limitations of Current Models

Abstract

Nonhuman primate (NHP) studies that utilize simian immunodeficiency virus (SIV) to model human immunodeficiency virus (HIV-1) infection have proven to be powerful, highly informative research tools. However, there are substantial differences between SIV and HIV-1. Accordingly, there are numerous research questions for which SIV-based models are not well suited, including studies of certain aspects of basic HIV-1 biology, and pre-clinical evaluations of many proposed HIV-1 treatment, prevention, and vaccination strategies. To overcome these limitations of NHP models of HIV-1 infection, several groups have pursued the derivation of a minimally modified HIV-1 (mmHIV-1) capable of establishing pathogenic infection in macaques that authentically recapitulates key features of HIV-1 in humans. These efforts have focused on three complementary objectives: (1) engineering HIV-1 to circumvent species-specific cellular restriction factors that otherwise potently inhibit HIV-1 in macaques, (2) introduction of a C chemokine receptor type 5 (CCR5)-tropic envelope, ideally that can efficiently engage macaque CD4, and (3) correction of gene expression defects inadvertently introduced during viral genome manipulations. While some progress has been made toward development of mmHIV-1 variants for use in each of the three macaque species (pigtail, cynomolgus, and rhesus), model development progress has been most promising in pigtail macaques (PTMs), which do not express an HIV-1-restricting tripartite motif-containing protein 5 α (TRIM5α). In our work, we have derived a CCR5-tropic mmHIV-1 clone designated stHIV-A19 that comprises 94% HIV-1 genome sequence and replicates to high acute-phase titers in PTMs. In animals treated with a cell-depleting CD8α antibody at the time of infection, stHIV-A19 maintains chronically elevated plasma viral loads with progressive CD4+ T-cell loss and the development of acquired immune-deficiency syndrome (AIDS)-defining clinical endpoints. However, in the absence of CD8α+ cell depletion, no mmHIV-1 model has yet displayed high levels of chronic viremia or AIDS-like pathogenesis. Here, we review mmHIV-1 development approaches, the phenotypes, features, limitations, and potential utility of currently available mmHIV-1s, and propose future directions to further advance these models.

Keywords

• HIV-1
• AIDS
• SIV
• animal model
• nonhuman primate
• macaque