The Return of Not-Quite “Phantom Experts”? - The ICJ Meets with IPCC Scientists

Abstract

On Monday, 2 December 2024, the much anticipated hearing began in the Obligations of States in respect of Climate Change advisory proceedings before the International Court of Justice. Less than a week before the start of the hearing, the Court issued a brief and unusual press release about a meeting that it held with scientists from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). The Court’s decision to meet privately with the scientists raises questions about the Court’s procedures and its approach to evidence. Above all, it is unclear why the Court decided to consult with the IPCC scientists in a closed meeting rather than eliciting testimony from these individuals as part of the formal, public hearing.

Keywords

• Advisory Opinion
• Climate Crisis
• Expertise
• ICJ
• Internationaler Gerichtshof | Den Haag
• climate change litigation