Applied Sciences (Sep 2022)

Analytical, Stochastic and Experimental Solution of the Osteosynthesis of the Fifth Metatarsal by Headless Screw

  • Kateřina Vlčková,
  • Karel Frydrýšek,
  • Vojtěch Bajtek,
  • Jiří Demel,
  • Leopold Pleva,
  • Miroslav Havlíček,
  • Jana Pometlová,
  • Roman Madeja,
  • Jiří Kratochvíl,
  • Pavel Krpec,
  • Paweł Osemlak,
  • Kristina Čabanová,
  • Eva Olšovská,
  • Jana Vaculová

DOI
https://doi.org/10.3390/app12199615
Journal volume & issue
Vol. 12, no. 19
p. 9615

Abstract

Read online

This paper evaluates the various approaches to strength and stiffness analysis of fracture osteosynthesis using a headless Herbert screw. The problem has been extensively addressed using several scientific approaches, namely the analytical approach, stochastic approach, experimental approach, and (marginally) using the finite elements method. The problem is illustrated on the use of a prototype headless screw Ti: 4.0/1.4 × 30/7 (manufacturer: Medin, Czech Republic) and the surgical treatment of the fifth metatarsal fracture. Mathematical equations for the analytical calculation of the maximum stresses in the screw were established for tensile/compression loading. This problem is also interesting because of its static indetermination in tension and compression; for this reason, it was necessary to use the deformation condition, i.e., the relationship between screw extension and bone contraction. The stochastic (probabilistic) approach, i.e., application of the Monte Carlo method, takes advantage of the mathematical equations derived during the analytical solution by respecting of the natural variabilities and uncertainties. The analytical and stochastic approaches were validated by measurements on porcine bones and by the finite element method. The data measured experimentally were also processed and used for deriving an equation, appropriately approximating the data. The main part of the measurement was to determine the axial force generated during osteosynthesis with a headless screw. The obtained compressional force was used to determine the maximal stress in the screw and bone. Finally, the methods were compared. In this paper, comprehensive and original approaches based on the authors’ experience with multiple methods are presented. Obtained results are necessary for headless screw designers during optimalization of the implants and are also useful for surgeons developing new surgical techniques. This biomechanical problem was solved in cooperation with the engineering industry and physicians to improve the quality of care for patients with trauma in orthopedics and surgery.

Keywords