Developing a Consensus-Based POCUS Protocol for Critically Ill Patients During Pandemics: A Modified Delphi Study

Abstract

Background and Objectives: During pandemics, emergency departments face the challenge of managing critically ill patients with limited resources. Point-of-Care Ultrasound (POCUS) has emerged as a crucial diagnostic tool in such scenarios. This study aimed to develop a standardized POCUS protocol using expert consensus via a modified Delphi survey to guide physicians in managing these patients more effectively. Materials and Methods: A committee of emergency imaging experts and board-certified emergency physicians identified essential elements of POCUS in the treatment of patients under investigation (PUI) with shock, sepsis, or other life-threatening diseases. A modified Delphi survey was conducted among 39 emergency imaging experts who were members of the Korean Society of Emergency Medicine. The survey included three rounds of expert feedback and revisions, leading to the development of a POCUS protocol for critically ill patients during a pandemic. Results: The developed POCUS protocol emphasizes the use of POCUS-echocardiography and POCUS-lung ultrasound for the evaluation of cardiac and respiratory function, respectively. The protocol also provides guidance on when to consider additional tests or imaging based on POCUS findings. The Delphi survey results indicated general consensus on the inclusion of POCUS-echocardiography and POCUS-lung ultrasound within the protocol, although there were some disagreements regarding specific elements. Conclusions: Effective clinical practice aids emergency physicians in determining appropriate POCUS strategies for differential diagnosis between life-threatening diseases. Future studies should investigate the effectiveness and feasibility of the protocol in actual clinical scenarios, including its impact on patient outcomes, resource utilization, and workflow efficiency in emergency departments.

Keywords

• point-of-care systems
• pandemics
• emergency medicine
• critical care
• Delphi technique
• ultrasonography