Systems (Dec 2020)

Comparing Equation-Based and Agent-Based Data Generation Methods for Early Warning Signal Analysis

  • Daniel Reisinger,
  • Manfred Füllsack

DOI
https://doi.org/10.3390/systems8040054
Journal volume & issue
Vol. 8, no. 4
p. 54

Abstract

Read online

Dynamical systems are known to exhibit sudden state transitions, with abrupt shifts from one stable state to another. Such transitions are widely observed, with examples ranging from abrupt extinctions of species in ecosystems to unexpected financial crises in the economy or sudden changes in medical conditions. Statistical methods known as early warning signals (EWSs) are used to predict these transitions. In most studies to date, EWSs have been tested on data generated using equation-based methods that represent a system’s aggregate state and thus show limitations in considering the interactions of a system at the component level. Agent-based models offer an alternative without these limitations. This study compares the performance of EWSs when applied to data from an equation-based and from an agent-based version of the Ising model. The results provide a reason to consider agent-based modelling a promising complementary method for investigating the predictability of state changes with EWSs.

Keywords