Novel Insights into the Pathogenesis of Human Post-Primary Tuberculosis from Archival Material of the Pre-Antibiotic Era, 1931–1947

Abstract

Objectives: Primary and post-primary tuberculosis (TB) are distinct entities. The aim of this study was to study the histopathology of primary and post-primary TB by using the unique human autopsy material from the pre-antibiotic era, 1931–1947. Material and Methods: Autopsy data were collected from the autopsy journals, and the human tissue was collected from the pathology archives at the Department of Pathology, the Gades Institute. Results: Histological presentations of TB lesions showed great diversity within a single lung. Post-primary TB starts as a pneumonia forming early lesions, characterized by the infiltration of foamy macrophages containing mycobacterial antigens within alveoli, and progressing to necrotic pneumonias with an increasing density of mycobacterial antigens in the lesions. These necrotic pneumonic lesions appeared to either resolve as fibrocaseous lesions or lead to cavitation. The typical granulomatous inflammation, the hallmark of TB lesions, appeared later in the post-primary TB and surrounded the pneumonic lesions. These post-primary granulomas contained lesser mycobacterial antigens as compared to necrotic pneumonia. Conclusions: Immunopathogenesis of post-primary TB is different from primary TB and starts as pneumonia. The early lesions of post-primary TB may progress or regress, holding the key to understanding how a host can develop the disease despite an effective TB immunity.

Keywords

• primary tuberculosis
• post-primary tuberculosis
• tuberculosis pneumonia
• cavity