Achieving reproducible perovskite solar cell fabrication is crucial for making it a scalable technology. We demonstrate an automated gas quenching system to improve perovskite solar cell reproducibility at the lab-scale. We use in situ photoluminescence to monitor the perovskite film formation as a function of the atmosphere in the glove box and find that antisolvent quenching is more sensitive to lingering precursor solvents than the gas quenching method. We observe a better reproducibility with gas quenching than with antisolvent quenching because it maintains a more consistent atmosphere in the glove box. The automated gas quenching process leads to high performing devices that are reproducible both batch to batch and researcher to researcher. The insights into gas quenching film formation as a function of solvent atmosphere and quench velocity will help inform future studies on large scale fabrication systems.